BMW 335is vs Porsche Cayman S?

the E63 is great but it isnt in your range (obviously you wont buy the car with no options and extras) i would suggest the 335is because the cayman S is one of the cars that is unreliable, friends have/had that car and they have alot of problems with it, its a good driving car but get alot of problems, try find a used M3 because if i were you i would find a good used M3, (the current generation not that straight six tho) see the C63 tho, its a good car and around your budget and it will amaze you everyday. and the extra money you will spend on cayman S you can spend it on gas